The saying we all know and use is “I want to sleep like a baby”, but the truth is even babies deserve the best baby mattress so they can get an even better night’s sleep and hopefully allow you to get the rest you need as well. While it is hard to do a baby mattress review because, well, babies aren’t the most responsive to answering questions about how comfortable a mattress is. Weird I know. But we can use the tried and true methods of testing mattresses and apply them to mattresses for the wee ones.

We tested out all the top baby mattress brands out there and put them through a series of tests that tested their strength, durability, and we also relied heavily on customer reviews from people who actually have babies that use these mattresses. Out of all those brands, we narrowed it down to our top 5 and below you can see the features of each mattress along with the pros and cons of each one as well.


The Best Baby Mattress Review of 2017

[wpsm_comparison_table id=”6″ class=””]


What Makes The Best Baby Mattress, Well The Best?

You may not know that there’s a thing called Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). Fortunately, instances have considerably lessened because people became aware of it. The SIDS is caused when infants stay in the crib for more than 16 hours a day. The type of mattress you buy either lures or protects your baby from this unfortunate disease.

The Caveat Of A Long Warranty

Let us first address the elephant in the room before we begin. A lifetime warranty is good, but this does not translate to the quality of the mattresses they produce. Sometimes, this is just a marketing ploy to attain customer loyalty. Check the product first before you get lured by the after-sales services.  


Make sure the mattress is firm and has a tight bedding, this lowers the risks of your child being suffocated in their sleep. On a less serious note, a firm mattress also provides more comfort as compared to an adult bed. You might think a soft one is better, but your baby will slightly sink into it, giving them difficulty in adjusting their position. A firm mattress also allows optimal physical development of your child.


Moreover, look for a mattress that is waterproof and has a machine washable cover; apparently, your baby’s bed will frequently get peed and pooped on even if they’re wearing diapers. A waterproof mattress saves you time and prevents you from the inconvenience of washing your mattress.

Budget Friendly

The good news is, baby beds are not that expensive compared to typical mattresses for adults. A higher price is not always equivalent to it being the best baby mattress, and you can buy a good one even if you are on a tight budget. However, you have to pay more in cases of specialized baby mattresses.

You should never buy or use hand-me-downs. Some studies suggest that the use of secondhand mattresses is also one of the factors in the increased occurrence of SIDS.

Moreover, these may be unsanitary given that the previous owner’s child used it already and you do not know how this was maintained before it was handed (or sold) to you. Unclean mattresses are potential sites for dust mites. Needless to say, hand-me-downs have probably sagged or lost its support.

You may also be wondering if you can still use your old mattress to your second child. Yes, you can! As long as the bed was properly maintained and thoroughly cleansed. 

Foam vs Innerspring

Foam mattresses are much more durable than before, thanks to the advancement in technology. These are also more affordable and lighter than its innerspring counterparts. Choose a denser foam mattress, but make sure you can still lift it when you change sheets. After all, there should also be a balance between functionality and ease of use.

On the other hand, innerspring mattresses have coils inside them and are usually heavier than foam mattresses. These are also more expensive but are more durable. You should buy one that has around 135-150 coils with a gauge of 15.5 or lower. Also look for border rods, as these give an innerspring mattress more stability.

In the end, a foam mattress is more than enough for your child. The best ones are just as good as innerspring mattresses, and these cost less. You will also change sheets a lot, and a foam mattress makes this tasks a lot easier. Lastly, foam mattresses are less springy, which means that it will be less likely used as a trampoline when your kids get older.


Are Organic Mattresses A Real Thing?

We understand your intentions to go green, but this is still a gray area as far as mattresses are concerned. Organic mattresses are not yet regulated by the government, which gives manufacturers a way to mislead buyers with their claims.

Still, look for various certifications on a product if you want to make a statement. GREENGUARD and CertiPUR, for example, ensure the mattress has a low indoor emission of volatile compounds. The former also provides a stricter standard for more sensitive individuals. Other than that, these mattresses have undergone rigorous tests conducted by the government to ensure it is safe for final use.


The Best Baby Mattresses of 2017

Now let us help you in picking the best baby mattresses on the market. These might look the same at first glance, but it all comes down to the features. Are you looking for baby beds reviews? Look no further as we provide short assessment for the best ones right now.

1) Colgate Eco Classica III


The winner in our baby mattress review is the Colgate Eco Classica III. It is a 52-inch baby mattress that weighs around 10 pounds and probably its unique feature is its dual side nature – making this sellable as a kid’s bed.

Both sides are correctly labeled, with the one hand softer than the other, this was done so your child can still use it even when they become a toddler. The infant side is firm, and you will not have any worry about your baby sinking by lying there. On the other hand, the cover is made of 100% organic cotton, and the inner part is made from plant-based foam. Hence, this baby mattress is relatively lightweight, and your daunting task of changing sheets will be a breeze.

Are you going green? Colgate Eco Classica III passes an indoor quality test because it is GREENGUARD and CertiPUR certified. The latter also guarantees that this baby mattress is ecologically friendly by utilizing plant-oils. Well, you may be put off by its lack of smell, but most mattresses should have no smell upon purchase. The combination of firmness, lightweight body, and green features puts Colgate Eco Classica III an easy choice for best baby mattresses.



2) Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer



Similar to Colgate Eco Classic III, this baby mattress also has a dual-firmness feature that renders this usable for toddlers. However, Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer went ahead with its vinyl, polyethylene, PVC, and phthalates free mattress. The after-sales support is also good, as proved by happy customers who had their beds fixed.

Even better, this was designed to ensure the balance of firmness and softness for your infant to sleep soundly and still get the much-needed physical development. Another unique trait of this baby mattress is the stitching is on the side instead of on the top; this provides an easy way to clean spill-ups and preventing molds from growing up.

Lastly, this is also GREENGUARD, and CertiPUR certified. The cover is also waterproof and can be cleaned using a wet rag. While this is more expensive than the others in this list, the quality speaks of Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer’s legacy.



3) Sealy Soybean Foam-Core



While it lacks the dual-firmness feature, Sealy Soybean Foam-Core prides itself with its apparent green baby mattress. Note that we love this product, but its name is misleading as it is only about 25% soybean and is 73% polyurethane. Even so, Sealy Soybean Foam-Core is made from non-toxic material and mothers are mostly happy with it.

Do you prioritize cost over special features? If so, Sealy Soybean Foam-Core is a perfect choice for parents who have a modest budget for baby mattresses; this is waterproof and certified green which is the same with the above entries. On first use, this is firm enough for an infant, but it sags over time. Hence, you may not use this for your second child.

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core may not stand against others regarding sustained firmness, but this also boasts the best value for money in this list, all other things considered.



4) Naturepedic No-Compromise Organic Cotton Classic 150 Seamless Crib Mattress



The greenest and perhaps the most expensive baby mattress in the list, Naturepedic No Compromise made this 100% organic in all aspects. You also get the dual-firmness and the waterproof feature. Customer service is also excellent, but then again, it has to be given the $ 289.00 tag.

It delivers the basics of what you want in a baby mattress. However, do not expect that much since its price does not mean it is the best. There are reports where the final product is shorter than the standard 52-inch length and some sag in the middle parts.



5) Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams



If you think Sealy Soybean Foam-Core is still expensive, then you can opt with a budget baby mattress without compromising your child’s safety. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams gives the firmness and comfort its more expensive peers have, hence, this is a good buy. Other features like GREENGUARD certification, waterproof cover, and the weight are also present making this a must-buy for those who are tight on the budget.

However, this is made from polyurethane foam, that may be bad news for some. But, this costs less $50, that’s a pretty good bargain.



Final Words

These baby mattresses review highlight what is unique in these products. You may search the internet for other brands if you have other criteria in mind. Regardless of the brand, you buy in the end, remember the features that make a good mattress. You can never go wrong with putting the safety of your infant first before everything else.